From a legal standpoint, here are two main types of nonprofit
organizations: "foundations" and "civil
associations." There are also a limited number of nonprofit
organizations registered under a third category:
"organizations with a foreign component." The only
difference between "foundations" and
"associations" is the process of registration. The
approval of the municipal (local) authority is sufficient for the
registration of a foundation. An association of citizens must be
registered with the Ministry of Internal Affairs. For both types
of organizations, the other regulations are the same. The
citizenship (whether foreign or Slovak) of the founders of the
organization is not a factor. Registration involves only the
submission of a description of the goal of the organization and
the expected sources of financing. Internal statutes must also
exist for the organization. The founders are obliged to submit
the articles of association linking them, as well as data on
statutory representatives and anticipated sources of income.
NGO representatives evaluate the process of registration as
satisfactory, although they tend to feel it would be improved if
registration (incorporation) was supervised by commercial courts
rather than public administration offices, since NGOs also
develop commercial relationships. In addition, regulations
governing the establishment of voluntary organizations,
foundations and other NGOs, and their status ascribed in the
civil code, are considered somewhat unclear. The third sector and
the public administration feel the need for a clear,
comprehensive set of regulations, or at least a change in this
direction in the current regulations.
Proposed legislation on the third sector was on the agenda of
the previous government in 1994. Members of the Stupava
"Gremium of the Third Sector," who are representatives
of nonprofit organizations, cooperated closely with the deputy
prime minister, who was in charge of legislative affairs.
Nonetheless, the current government does not intend to improve
the legal framework for NGOs. On the other hand, the main effort
of NGOs is aimed at preventing acceptance of any legislation
which would maintain the status quo.
Since 1992, the right of individual entrepreneurs and legal
entities supplying social services to promote their activities
has been recognized. A contribution is usually provided by local
municipalities. Public authorities do not have their own funds
for financing public social sector facilities. The biggest
problems are caused by legislation regarding the financing of the
third sector. According to the more radical view, current
legislation tends to favor the elimination of the third sector
and thus undermine democracy. Legislation in the sphere of
financing of the third sector did not solve the problem of
support by entrepreneur subjects (sponsorship) successfully up to
now. It resulted in the third sector being strongly dependent on
state financial sources. Because of this dependency, the
development of the third sector cannot be free in all necessary
directions. Distribution of finances can be influenced by
political decisions or subjectivism. Eventually, this could
sharply erode third sector activities and greatly diminish
alternative possibilities for solving societal problems .(Jozef
Sabo, IFO; Peter Mariánek, Movement Human).
In the first place, taxes are a matter of concern. The system
of taxation favors only to a very limited degree, enterprises
which may wish to sponsor NGO projects. It makes it possible to
give a donation and thereby decrease taxable income, but only up
to 2 percent of net profit. NGO representatives consider that the
optimum solution would involve enabling business entities to
donate a part (approximately 5 percent) of their tax bill
directly to voluntary organizations as is the practice elsewhere
in Europe and in other regions.
Nonprofit organizations are taxed in the same way as business
entities. They must pay taxes on all activities which generate
profits. NGOs are also liable to pay the value added tax (6 or 25
percent, depending on the situation) whenever they make any
purchase, as well as when they receive donated goods from abroad.
In practice, this leads to situations in which valuable
instruments from abroad (for example, hospital equipment) or
donated books are blocked at the border because the beneficiary
institution does not have the money to pay the value added tax on
these items. Charitable organizations have been exempted from the
payment of customs duties by a 1994 decree of the Ministry of
Finance, but whether this also applies to the value added tax is
not clear. In any case, the exemption involves only a limited
number of organizations. An objective is to extend the exemption
to the entire third sector. However, this is impossible without
clear legal recognition of the status of the third sector.
Insurance for health care, the welfare system and pensions
represent significant problems for NGOs. Thirty-eight percent of
each employee wage must be paid out for insurance coverage. The
employee pays 12 percent, and the employer, including NGOs, must
pay the remainder. In addition, the rest of the wage is
progressively taxed between 10 to 42 percent. According to
regulations, NGOs are liable to pay insurance even for those who
are otherwise unemployed, to whom they offer jobs within the
framework of community service programs. However, the unemployed
status of these people is not legally changed; and, therefore,
the state should probably be responsible for the insurance
coverage.
The current situation in parliament, as well as the
legislative program of the government, does not offer much hope
that changes will soon be made. The Constitution provides that
only these two bodies#151;not the president#151;can initiate
legislation.
The former government, which was in office for just six months
(from March 1994 until the elections on September 30, 1994), was
mainly concerned with trying to enforce all laws and measures
that would guarantee the irreversibility of the transition to a
market economy. The significance of the third sector was not
appreciated. Despite this, in October 1994, the Ministry of
Finance submitted the Foundations Act, which was examined by the
Legislative Committee of government, as well as by lawyers and
NGO representatives. It was found to be insufficient, hence a
seminar has been planned to discuss suggested changes. This was
to have been organized under the auspices of the Ministry of
Finance and the Gremium of the Third Sector.
The present government came into office in December 1994.
Since then, nothing has been done in this area. |